Before 1920, our list of pastors is incomplete and there is considerable overlap.  It is possible that the nineteenth-century pastors were not serving under annual appointments.  From 1920 on the record is clear.

1859   G.W. Sizer
1860   Robert Codling
1861   Henry Hatfield
1861   C.E. Glover
1863   E.H. Fanning
1864   William Wake
1865   Hart F. Pease
1866   Samuel W. King
1867   Seymour Landon
1868   S.F. Johnson
1869   B.F. Reeve
1907 (1) P. E. Shoemaker

==

1913-1921 (2) William Dalziel
1921-1922   Joshua L. Robinson
1922-1926   Francis P. Lamphear
1926-1928   Robert E. Cordell
1928-1931   G. Whitefield Simonson
1931-1938   E. Ralph Wiburg
1938-1940   Wendell J. Clark
1940-1951   Donald M. Runyon
1951-1961   Harry D. Robinson
1961-1966   Richard A. Purnell
1966-1969   Avery C. Manchester
1969-1975   Charles Wesley Lee
1975-1983   Norma A. Rust
1983-1984   David Stevens
1984-1995   Jeffrey Glassey
1995-1998   Carol O’Hanlon
1998-2001   Albert Hahn
2001-2005   Julia Y.H. Yim
2005-2008   Young Shik Kim
2006-2008   Westley Villazon (Associate)
NOTES:
(1) Received postcard postmarked 1907
(2) Listed as pastor in 1913 dedication of St Marks bldg.
     Continuous service assumed before 1920.